Kinsey and the Psychoanalysts: Cross-Disciplinary Knowledge Production in Post-War US Sex Research (2021)
Sutton, Katie (Author)
History of the Human Sciences
Volume: 34
Issue: 1
Pages: 120-147
Publication date: 2021
Language: English
The historical forces of war and migration impacted heavily on the disciplinary locations, practitioners, and structures of sexology and psychoanalysis that had developed in the first decades of the 20th century. By the late 1940s, the US was fast becoming the world centre of each of these prominent fields within the modern human sciences. During these years, the work of Alfred C. Kinsey and his team became synonymous with a distinctly North American brand of empirical sex research. This article offers the most nuanced account to date of the shifting relationship between these two fields in the late 1940s to mid 1950s. It argues that this was more collaborative and mutually influential than previous historians have assumed, even as, following the publication of the first ‘Kinsey report’, tensions grew between the Indiana team and the conservative brand of psychoanalysis that by this stage dominated 1950s North American psychiatry. A keen sense of professional competitiveness accelerated the growing split between these two fields, as Kinsey’s team developed a distinctly modern, technologized brand of statistically oriented sexology that contrasted with the older patient case history, and assumed a very different approach to conservative analysts on ideas of homosexuality and ‘normal’ sexual behaviour. Yet this story of divergence is also tempered through consideration of other aspects of ‘situated knowledge’ such as religion and gender identity, even as accounts of cross-disciplinary competitiveness are expanded by contrasting Kinsey’s positions on psychoanalysis with those of contemporaries such as Harry Benjamin.
...MoreArticle Kirsten Leng; Katie Sutton (2021) Histories of Sexology Today: Reimagining the Boundaries of Scientia Sexualis. History of the Human Sciences (pp. 3-9).
Similar Citations
Book
Hegarty, Peter;
(2013)
Gentlemen's Disagreement: Alfred Kinsey, Lewis Terman, and the Sexual Politics of Smart Men
Article
Tabea Cornel;
(2021)
Contested Numbers: The failed negotiation of objective statistics in a methodological review of Kinsey et al.’s sex research
Thesis
Gorchov, Lynn Karen;
(2003)
Sexual Science and Sexual Politics: American Sex Research, 1920--1956
Thesis
Drucker, Donna J.;
(2008)
Creating the Kinsey Reports: Intellectual and Methodological Influences on Alfred Kinsey's Sex Research, 1919--1953
Article
Drucker, Donna J.;
(2012)
“A Most Interesting Chapter in the History of Science”: Intellectual Responses to Alfred Kinsey's Sexual Behavior in the Human Male
Chapter
Jane Russo;
Sérgio Carrara;
Alain Giami;
Sharman Levinson;
(2021)
Politics, Religion, and Sexuality: Psychoanalysis and Sexology in the Brazilian Publishing Market in the First Decades of the Twentieth Century
Book
Drucker, Donna J.;
(2014)
The Classification of Sex: Alfred Kinsey and the Organization of Knowledge
Chapter
Kateřina Lišková;
Alain Giami;
Sharman Levinson;
(2021)
Sexology’s Unexpected Progressiveness in the Cold War East: Shaping People’s Sexual Selves, Creating Socialist Societies
Article
Irwin, Robert;
(2009)
“To Try and Find Out What Is Being Done to Whom, by Whom and with What Results”: The Creation of Psychosexual Counselling Policy in England, 1972--1979
Article
Anya Jabour;
(2022)
Out of the closet? Reconstructing the personal life of pioneering sex researcher Katharine Bement Davis
Article
Rutherford, Alexandra;
(2012)
Problems of Sex and the Problem with Nature: A Commentary on “Beyond Kinsey”
Article
Drucker, Donna J.;
(2013)
Keying Desire: Alfred Kinsey's Use of Punched-Card Machines for Sex Research
Chapter
Alexandre Paturel;
Véronique Mottier;
Cynthia Kraus;
Alain Giami;
Sharman Levinson;
(2021)
Saving Sexual Science: Kinsey and American Religious-Conservative Politics
Chapter
Churchill, Frederick B.;
(2005)
The Evolutionary Ethics of Alfred C. Kinsey
Book
Garton, Stephen;
(2004)
Histories of Sexuality
Article
William Simon;
Robert J. Stoller;
(2020)
Documents: ‘How much closer to Freud's very nervous, sexual world I feel than to that of my students’: Correspondence between Sexology and Psychoanalysis, 1988–9
Article
Jeffrey Rubel;
(2022)
‘You never need an analyst with Bobby around’: The mid-20th-century human sciences in Sondheim and Furth's musical Company
Chapter
Forrester, John;
(2007)
The Psychoanalytic Case: Voyeurism, Ethics, and Epistemology in Robert Stoller's Sexual Excitement
Book
JPat Brown;
B. C. D. Lipton;
Michael Morisy;
(2019)
Scientists Under Surveillance: The FBI Files
Article
Gilbert Herdt;
(2020)
Robert J. Stoller in the Clinic and the Village
Be the first to comment!