Inference by Analogy and the Progress of Knowledge: From Reflection to Determination in Judgements of Natural Purpose (2015)
Stovall, Preston (Author)
British Journal for the History of Philosophy
Volume: 23
Issue: 4
Pages: 681-709
Publication date: 2015
Language: English
In this paper, I argue that Darwin's On the Origin of Species can be interpreted as the culmination of an extended exercise of what Kant called ‘the reflecting power of judgement’ that issued in a form of reasoning that Hegel associates with inference by analogy and that Peirce associates with hypothesis and later assimilates to abduction. After some exegetical and rationally reconstructive work, I support this reading by (1) showing that Darwin's theory of natural selection gave us a way of understanding the purposive character of organic generation and growth that does not rely on an analogy with intentional agency and (2) outlining some of the uses to which this new understanding was put in reasoning about mind and society by American intellectuals in the second half of the nineteenth century. In the process I hope to shed some light on the relationship between mechanistic and purposive explanation in judgements of nature.
...MoreArticle Robert Stern (2015) Introduction. British Journal for the History of Philosophy (pp. 601-610).
Similar Citations
Article
Paul Franks;
(2015)
Peirce's ‘Schelling-Fashioned Idealism’ and ‘the Monstrous Mysticism of the East’
Chapter
Ruse, Michael;
(2010)
Evolution and the Idea of Social Progress
Article
Ruse, Michael;
(2005)
Darwinism and Mechanism: Metaphor in Science
Article
Gayon, Jean;
(2010)
Sexual Selection: Another Darwinian Process
Book
Novoa, Adriana;
Levine, Alex;
(2010)
From Man to Ape: Darwinism in Argentina, 1870--1920
Article
Smith, Roger;
(2013)
Why and How Do I Write the History of Science?
Book
Emanuele Clarizio;
(2024)
La vita tecnica: Una filosofia biologica della tecnica
Article
Beiser, Frederick;
(2003)
Hegel and Naturphilosophie
Article
Thomas Khurana;
(2009)
Selbstorganisation und Selbstgesetzgebung. Form und Grenze einer Analogie in der Philosophie Kants und Hegels
Chapter
Tolman, Charles W.;
(2001)
Philosophic Doubts About Psychology as a Natural Science
Book
Dudley, Will;
(2008)
Understanding German Idealism
Book
Düsing, Klaus;
(2002)
Subjektivität und Freiheit: Untersuchungen zum Idealismus von Kant bis Hegel
Book
Bowler, Peter J.;
(2003)
Evolution: The History of an Idea
Chapter
Renn, Jürgen;
(2004)
The Paradox of Scientific Progress: Notes on the Foundations of a Historical Theory of Knowledge
Book
Kelley, Theresa M.;
(2012)
Clandestine Marriage: Botany and Romantic Culture
Article
Zammito, John H.;
(2008)
A Text of Two Titles: Kant's “A Renewed Attempt to Answer the Question: “Is the Human Race Continually Improving?””
Thesis
Pajewski, Alessandro;
(2012)
The Face of Nature: Hume and Darwin on Analogy and Emotion
Article
Airaksinen, Timo;
(2011)
Rhetoric and Corpuscularism in Berkeley's Siris
Book
Dunér, David;
(2013)
The Natural Philosophy of Emanuel Swedenborg: A Study in the Conceptual Metaphors of the Mechanistic World-View
Chapter
Kaitaro, Timo;
(2007)
Technological Metaphors and the Anatomy of Representations in Eighteenth-Century French Materialism and Dualist Mechanism
Be the first to comment!