IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB001421072

Surveying the Meritocracy: The Problems of Intelligence and Mobility in the Studies of the Population Investigation Committee (2014)

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Volume: 47, Part A
Issue: Part A
Pages: 130-141
Publication date: 2014
Language: English

Publication Date: 2014
Edition Details: Article in a special section: “Heredity and the Study of Human Populations After 1945”

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Public policy Eugenics Demography; population research Surveys Intelligence tests Social sciences 20th century Great Britain

The post-war era saw the emergence of large-scale and longitudinal social and medical surveys in Britain. That these surveys were both representative of an entire nation and could follow individuals throughout their lives, gave them a privileged position in relation to policy-making. This paper will focus on two closely interrelated surveys, both instigated by the Population Investigation Committee at London School of Economics---the National Survey of Health and Development, which began in 1946, and the Scottish Mental Survey of 1947. These surveys had a critical role in educational research and policy and, more specifically, in changing perspectives regarding the concept and measurement of intelligence. They were seen to privilege social and environmental factors as determinants of mental ability, and they shifted attention away from genetic factors and eugenic concerns. However, while the surveys were indeed powerful tools, their structure, the questions they asked, the methods they used and the choices made over the data to be tabulated, also determined what could be known. The paper will examine the growing criticism and debate over the large-scale survey. Many argued that smaller-scale studies were more effective in understanding the social and biological causes of intellectual differences, and better for identifying the benefits and dangers of using intelligence and merit as a means of organising society.

...More

Included in

Article Bangham, Jenny; Chadarevian, Soraya de (2014) Human Heredity after 1945: Moving Populations Centre Stage. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences (pp. 45-49). unapi

Citation URI

stagingisis.isiscb.org/p/isis/citation/CBB001421072

This citation is part of the Isis database.

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Book Mespoulet, Martine; (2008)
Construire le socialisme par les chiffres: enquêtes et recensements en URSS de 1917 à 1991

Article Ramsden, Edmund; (2007)
A Differential Paradox: The Controversy Surrounding the Scottish Mental Surveys of Intelligence and Family Size

Article Ramsden, Edmund; (2009)
Confronting the Stigma of Eugenics: Genetics, Demography and the Problems of Population

Article Kruke, Anja; Woyke, Meik; (2010)
Editorial

Article Ramsden, Edmund; (2008)
Eugenics from the New Deal to the Great Society: Genetics, Demography andPopulation Quality

Article Ballester, R.; Porras, M-I; (2009)
El significado histórico de las encuestas de seroprevalencia como tecnología de laboratorio aplicada a las campañas de inmunización. El caso de la poliomielitis en España

Article Gazeley, Ian; Langhamer, Claire; (2013)
The Meanings of Happiness in Mass Observation's Bolton

Article Harry Parker; (2023)
The regional survey movement and popular autoethnography in early 20th-century Britain

Book Oakley, Ann; (2011)
A Critical Woman: Barbara Wootton, Social Science and Public Policy in the Twentieth Century

Book Zenderland, Leila; (1998)
Measuring Minds: Henry Herbert Goddard and the Origins of American Intelligence Testing

Article Ann Marie Ryan; (2019)
Catholic Minds/Bodies–Souls: Catholic Schools and Eugenic Inspired Educational Reforms in the United States, 1915–1952

Book Murdoch, Stephen; (2007)
IQ: A Smart History of a Failed Idea

Article Jones, Ross; (2009)
Removing Some of the Dust from the Wheels of Civilization: William Ernest Jones and the 1928 Commonwealth Survey of Mental Deficiency

Article Hideki Yui; (2022)
A History of Japanese Follow-up Surveys of Children Conceived through Artificial Insemination by Donor: The Evidence of “Superior” Children and Positive Eugenics

Book Dowbiggin, Ian Robert; (2008)
The Sterilization Movement and Global Fertility in the Twentieth Century

Chapter Ramsden, Edmund; (2013)
Remodelling the Boundaries of Normality: Lionel S. Penrose and Population Surveys of Mental Ability

Article Reggiani, Andrés Horacio; (2002)
Alexis Carrel Unkown: Eugenics and Population Research under Vichy

Article Wright, Maureen; (2014)
A Man `[a]s Black as the Devil Himself': The Radical Life of Benjamin J. Elmy, Secularist, Anti-Eugenicist and `First-Wave' Feminist in Britain (1838--1906)

Article Renwick, Chris; (2011)
From Political Economy to Sociology: Francis Galton and the Social-Scientific Origins of Eugenics

Article Lawrence, Christopher; (2009)
Degeneration under the Microscope at the fin se siècle